Lies, statistics and why Africa’s poor numbers really matter

By Mandy de Waal / Africa Check (www.africacheck.org), a non-partisan organisation which promotes accuracy in public debate.

Poor NumbersHow trustworthy are Africa’s gross domestic product (GDP) figures? These all-important statistics have taken on a “dangerously misleading air of accuracy”, writes economic historian Morten Jerven in his book, “Poor Numbers: How We Are Misled by African Development Statistics and What to Do About It“.

South Africa is Africa’s biggest economy with a GDP of about $384-billion in 2012. By comparison the most populous country on the continent, Nigeria, had a GDP of just $262-billion. This could change soon and dramatically so. For some time now, Nigeria’s statisticians have been hard at work revising the numbers that are used to measure the country’s economic health and success. Nigeria is changing the base year that it uses to calculate GDP. A change in the base year will be significant because it is the benchmark for all calculations used in computing the GDP of a nation. As a result, economists say, the country’s GDP could be revised upwards by as much as 40% or 50%.

In his book economic historian Morten Jerven tells the story of how Ghana did exactly the same thing in 2010. After that country’s statistical service adjusted the GDP by 60%, Ghana was no longer “Africa’s statistical tragedy” but had suddenly made the leap from being a poor country to a middle-class one. The change had significant consequences, because GDP is such a highly valued index in global economic terms. GDP shows whether economies are expanding or contracting. It is used to set interest rates and to plan economic policy. The index can influence the performance of stock exchanges as well as contributions that states make to economic unions, and affects whether countries receive aid.

The big question Jerven examines in his book is whether GDP numbers can be trusted in Africa. Needless to say, the answer is reflected in the title of the book. The author says the reason for these numbers being poor is not just one of technical accuracy, but also because the “arbitrariness of the quantification process produces observations with very large errors and levels of uncertainty”. Disturbingly, Jerven explains that these all-important statistics have taken on “a dangerously misleading air of accuracy, and the resulting figures are used to make critical decisions that allocate scarce resources”. “International development actors are making judgments based on erroneous statistics. Governments are not able to make informed decisions because existing data are too weak or the data they need do not exist.”

Travelling through Ghana, Nigeria, Uganda, Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi, Zambia and Botswana, the author takes readers into that heart of where and how GDP is constructed, and with what degree of accuracy. “Poor Numbers” should be required reading for anyone who wants to know whether the continent’s key figures for measuring economic health are accurate. The book is divided into four parts. The first looks at what is known about income and growth in Africa, and it is here that Jerven shows how GDP can be — and is — manipulated. The second section called “Measuring African Wealth and Progress” examines sub-Saharan Africa and looks at how national accounts were set up in this region, and the problems that emerged during this process. Chapter three – “Facts, Assumptions, and Controversy: Lessons from the Datasets” – looks at why the quality of statistics matters, and uses case studies to show what happens when several versions of the same dataset are in direct conflict with one another. Jerven then extrapolates very useful lessons about what happens when the data used to assess development in African states is in a “precarious” state. The final section of the book offers pragmatic advice and useful steps for improving the statistics used to measure Africa’s economic health.

gdp-growth-2013

As Jerven writes: “African development statistics tell us less than we would like to think about income, poverty and growth in the region. One of the most urgent challenges in African economic development is to devise a strategy for improving statistical capacity, This system currently causes more confusion than enlightenment.” Africa’s sun is rising and economists debating whether the continent’s robust growth is sustainable would be wise to broaden their argument to include the robustness of Africa’s numbers. Although Jerven’s book is one of the first on Africa’s “poor numbers”, it is a subject that’s going to get increasing attention given the interest in the continent together with the focus in global markets on governance, open data and transparency.

Morten Jerven, “Poor Numbers: How We Are Misled by African Development Statistics and What to Do About It“, February 2013, p. 176.

Further information
To understand national accounting and how GDP is configured, read “Lies, damn lies and GDP“, Morten Jerven’s article on Guardian.

This entry was posted in Book Reviews, English, Nigeria, South Africa.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *